| Billingham Town | 1-4 | FC Isle of Man |
| Andrew Nelson (1) | HT: 0-2 Att: 222 |
Luke Murray (12) Karl Clark (41) Charlie Higgins (77) Luke Murray (90+4) |
| Starting XI | Starting XI | |
| 1 | James Rice | |
| 2 | Karl Clark | |
| 3 | Jacob Crook |
| 4 | Jack McVey | |
| 5 | Sean Quaye | |
| 6 | Kyle Watson | |
| 7 | Stephen Whitley | |
| 8 | Tiernan Garvey | |
| 9 | Ciaran McNulty | |
| 10 | Luke Murray | |
| 11 | Adam Mealin |
| Substitutes | Substitutes | |
| S1 | Alex Maitland | |
| S2 | Charlie Higgins | |
| S3 | Dean Leece | |
| S4 | Lewis Roberts | |
| S5 | Thomas Creer |