| Games | Won | Drew | Lost | Scored | Conceded |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 27 | 7 | 6 | 14 | 38 | 53 |
| F.A. Challenge Cup | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat 06/08/16 | Penistone Church | 1-3 | Cheadle Town | HT: 1-1 |
| Danny Joynes (1) | Michael Sherrington (34) James Dunn (53) Luke Hincks (81) | Att: 175 | ||
| Sat 05/08/17 | Charnock Richard | 3-4 | Penistone Church | HT: 2-3 |
| Nathan Fairhurst (7p) Luke Barrow (33) Matthew Davison (67) |
Jordan Barnett (35) Jordan Barnett (37) Jordan Corduri (42) Scott Whittington (76) | Att: 254 | ||
| Sat 19/08/17 | Penistone Church | 2-0 | Litherland REMYCA | HT: 1-0 |
| Jordan Coduri (35) Kieran Ryan (85) |
Att: 208 | |||
| Sat 11/08/18 | Penistone Church | 2-1 | Bootle | HT: 1-1 |
| Kieran Ryan (27) Nathan Keightley (70) |
Carl Peers (42) | Att: 165 | ||
| Sat 25/08/18 | Penistone Church | 1-3 | Runcorn Town | HT: 0-1 |
| Sam Scrivens (53) | John Shaw (13) Ryan Cox (23) Shaun Weaver (74) | Att: 207 | ||
| Fri 09/08/19 | Skelmersdale United | 1-1 | Penistone Church | HT: 0-0 |
| Einar White (57) | Shaun Mundy (75) | Att: 99 | ||
| Wed 14/08/19 | Penistone Church | 2-5 | Skelmersdale United | HT: 1-2 |
| Tom Cadzow (39) Nathan Keightley (81) |
Alex Griffiths (32) John Keatley (37) Matthew Scoullar (63) Einar White (70) Own Goal (75) | Att: 256 | ||
| Tue 01/09/20 | Skelmersdale United | 3-2 | Penistone Church | HT: 0-2 |
| Emini Adegbenro (46) Emini Adegbenro (56p) Joe Herbert (84) |
Cameron Simpson (25) Cameron Simpson (40) | Att: 209 | ||
| Sat 07/08/21 | Lower Breck | 0-0 | Penistone Church | HT: 0-0 |
| Att: 165 | ||||
| Wed 11/08/21 | Penistone Church | 1-2 | Lower Breck | HT: 1-1 |
| Luke Stewart (32) | Jamie McDonald (45) Anthony Brown (50) | Att: 302 | ||
| Sat 06/08/22 | Lower Breck | 0-2 | Penistone Church | HT: 0-1 |
| Tom Charlesworth (31) Nathan Keighthley (84) | Att: 104 | |||
| Sat 19/08/23 | Penistone Church | 0-2 | Prestwich Heys | HT: 0-1 |
| Malachi Slaven (28) Tyler James (77) | Att: 254 | |||
| Sat 03/08/24 | Penistone Church | 1-2 | Charnock Richard | HT: 1-1 |
| Nathan Keightley (12) | Nathan Nickeas (25p) Brad Carsley (74) | Att: 321 |
| F.A. Carlsberg Vase | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat 06/09/14 | Atherton Collieries | 4-0 | Penistone Church | HT: 2-0 |
| Bradley Cooke (29) Matt Grimshaw (33) Mark Battersby (67) Matthew Boland (72) |
Att: 119 | |||
| Sat 24/09/16 | Penistone Church | 3-2 | West Didsbury & Chorlton | HT: 0-0 |
| Brett Lovell (63) Dan Joynes (90) Dan Joynes (115) |
Matty Kay (74) Rob Black (77) | Att: 121 | ||
| (After Extra Time, 2-2 after 90 mins) | ||||
| Sat 09/09/17 | Barnton | P-P | Penistone Church | |
| NULL | NULL | |||
| Postponed due to waterlogged pitch | ||||
| Tue 12/09/17 | Barnton | 3-1 | Penistone Church | HT: 0-1 |
| Ryan Malone (55) Christopher Bandell (80) Jack Irlam (87) |
Brett Lovell (8) | Att: 35 | ||
| Sat 01/09/18 | Shelley | 2-1 | Penistone Church | HT: 1-1 |
| Israel Johnson (42) Daniel Keane (54) |
Sam Scrivens (4) | Att: 225 | ||
| Sat 19/09/20 | Penistone Church | 2-2 | Prestwich Heys | HT: 1-0 |
| Andy Ring (8) Nsthan Emery (59) |
Jack Coop (48p) Jack Coop (68p) | Att: 144 | ||
| (Penistone Church won 5-4 on penalties) | ||||
| Sat 10/10/20 | Penistone Church | 2-1 | Wythenshawe | HT: 2-0 |
| Danny Howes (4) Charlie Baird (44) |
Sharif Islam Deans Mussa (88) | Att: 280 | ||
| Sat 31/10/20 | Penistone Church | 3-0 | AFC Liverpool | HT: 2-0 |
| Jordan Coduri (29) Brett Lovell (41) Kieran Ryan (83) |
Att: 266 | |||
| Sat 05/12/20 | Longridge Town | P-P | Penistone Church | |
| NULL | NULL | |||
| Postponed due to waterlogged pitch. Now 12th December. | ||||
| Sat 12/12/20 | Longridge Town | 1-1 | Penistone Church | HT: 1-0 |
| Owen Watkinson (28) | Nick Guest (71) | Att: 150 | ||
| (Longridge Town won 6-5 on penalties) | ||||
| Sat 11/09/21 | Bacup Borough | 1-0 | Penistone Church | HT: 1-0 |
| Lewis-Simon Byrne (28) | Att: 122 | |||
| Sat 24/09/22 | Maine Road | 1-1 | Penistone Church | HT: 1-1 |
| Francesco Frangillo (15) | Thomas Brennon (35) | Att: 127 | ||
| (Penistone Church won 4-3 on penalties) | ||||
| Sat 22/10/22 | FC St Helens | 2-1 | Penistone Church | HT: 0-0 |
| Joe Barker (51) Joe Barker (70) |
Own Goal (82) | Att: 172 | ||
| Sat 26/08/23 | Lower Breck | 3-0 | Penistone Church | HT: 0-0 |
| Thomas McNamara (48) James Murphy (49) Michael Fitzgerald (90+1) |
Att: 120 | |||
| Sat 21/09/24 | Abbey Hey | 4-2 | Penistone Church | HT: 2-0 |
| Saul Henderson (25) Saul Henderson (45+1) Saul Henderson (51) Jake Forshaw (74) |
Nathan Keightley (79) Kieran Ryan (88) | Att: 114 | ||
| Sheffield & Hallamshire Senior Cup | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wed 10/01/24 | Penistone Church | 3-2 | Shelley | HT: 1-2 |
| Nathan Keightley (30) Leon Hurles-Brook (48) Nathan Keightley (81) |
Thomas Rose (19) Curtis Broadfield (25) | Att: 142 |
