| Games | Won | Drew | Lost | Scored | Conceded |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 26 | 20 |
| F.A. Challenge Cup | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat 11/08/12 | Newton Aycliffe | 1-1 | Holker Old Boys | HT: 1-0 |
| Paul Robinson (2) | Conor Erdis (50) | Att: 137 | ||
| Tue 14/08/12 | Holker Old Boys | 3-0 | Newton Aycliffe | HT: 0-0 |
| Phil Coombe (71) Gareth Smith (78) Stephen Forbes (81) |
Att: 101 | |||
| Sat 15/08/15 | Nelson | 0-4 | Newton Aycliffe | HT: 0-1 |
| Dennis Knight (28) Stuart Banks (58) Matthew Moffat (81) Matthew Moffat (85) | Att: 96 |
| F.A. Carlsberg Vase | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sat 14/12/91 | Newton Aycliffe | 2-4 | Burscough | |
| (After Extra Time, 2-2 after 90 mins) | ||||
| Sat 06/09/14 | Daisy Hill | 3-2 | Newton Aycliffe | HT: 1-2 |
| Martin Hastings (43) Jordan Hussey (73p) Tim Raines (86) |
Thomas Atkinson (16) Zak Boaggy (24) | Att: 71 | ||
| Sat 03/10/15 | Newton Aycliffe | 3-0 | Barnoldswick Town | HT: 0-0 |
| Dennis Knight (52) Paul Gawthwaite (52) Jordan laidlow (90) |
Att: 63 | |||
| Sat 21/11/15 | Colne | 3-5 | Newton Aycliffe | |
| Danny Boyle (62) Jason Hart (76p) Chris Anderson (82) |
Dennis Knight (11p) Dennis Knight (44) Stuart Banks (63) Dennis Knight (92p) lan Harrison (115) | Att: 216 | ||
| (After Extra Time, 3-3 after 90 mins) | ||||
| Sat 12/12/15 | Newton Aycliffe | P-P | Atherton Collieries | |
| Postponed due to waterlogged pitch | ||||
| Tue 15/12/15 | Newton Aycliffe | P-P | Atherton Collieries | |
| Postponed due to Due to snowbound pitch | ||||
| Tue 22/12/15 | Newton Aycliffe | P-P | Atherton Collieries | |
| Postponed due to waterlogged pitch | ||||
| Tue 05/01/16 | Newton Aycliffe | P-P | Atherton Collieries | |
| Postponed due to waterlogged pitch | ||||
| Sat 09/01/16 | Newton Aycliffe | P-P | Atherton Collieries | |
| Postponed due to Waterlogged pitch | ||||
| Tue 12/01/16 | Newton Aycliffe | 1-0 | Atherton Collieries | HT: 0-0 |
| Stuart Banks (55) | Att: 101 | |||
| at Durham City FC | ||||
| Sat 19/09/20 | Newton Aycliffe | 4-0 | Barnoldswick Town | HT: 2-0 |
| Connor Phelan (18) Liam Jarvie (35) Adam Burnicle (46) Jake Petitjean (64) |
Att: 104 | |||
| Sat 31/10/20 | Lower Breck | 3-2 | Newton Aycliffe | HT: 2-1 |
| Own Goal (4) Joseph Lynch (33) Own Goal (90) |
Ethan Wood (25) Jake Petitjean (84p) | Att: 118 | ||
| Sat 11/09/21 | Campion | 3-3 | Newton Aycliffe | HT: 1-1 |
| Leon Hurles-Brook (37) Aidan Kirby (83) Mark Ferguson (85) |
Andrei-Vasile Ardelean (45+2) Jake Pettisean (49p) Callum Munro (81) | Att: 100 | ||
| (Newton Aycliffe won 3-2 on penalties) | ||||
| Sun 24/10/21 | AFC Liverpool | 2-1 | Newton Aycliffe | HT: 1-1 |
| Kyle Schorah (31) Kyle Schorah (47) |
Ben Dibb-Fuller (4) | Att: 127 | ||
